Scarred by her experience of renting in a brand-new building, a first-time buyer looked at ‘nice old apartments’ and tried to survive a few bidding wars. Here’s where she landed.

Jaime Archer didn’t plan to buy a home at 27. The only child of a single mother, Ms. Archer expected that one day, after her mother died, she might inherit enough to scrape together a down payment.

But then her mother made a surprising proposal: Rather than disbursing all of her money in her will, she would bequeath some of it earlier if Ms. Archer was interested in buying an apartment. After enduring two years’ worth of problems in her newly built rental in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, Ms. Archer was.

“I know that nobody really has a good rental experience, but mine was quite bad,” said Ms. Archer, the editorial operations manager for a media company. “I came to realize that things that are new construction aren’t built very well.”

Start-up headaches, like a lack of mail and trash service, had vexed her since the beginning of the lease. And the longer she lived in her apartment, the more she noticed small construction issues, like drywall without caulk on the seams and tiles caked with dried grout.

She brought her concerns to her landlord, with the help of Frank Seegitz, a broker with Douglas Elliman who had represented the developer. “She was the first person in the building,” Mr. Seegitz said. “I advocated for her.”

[Did you recently buy or rent a home in the New York metro area? We want to hear from you. Email: thehunt@nytimes.com]

His support was enough to earn Ms. Archer’s trust, so when her mother offered the money, Ms. Archer turned to Mr. Seegitz to help find a one-bedroom nearby. One of the first things she told him was that she had realized that modern was not her aesthetic.

“I went in the exact opposite direction, looking at very nice old apartments to buy, because I did not want to do the new-construction thing anymore,” she said.

With her own savings and her mother’s help on a down payment, Ms. Archer figured she could spend up to $700,000, although she hoped to stay closer to $600,000.

Mr. Seegitz encouraged her to begin looking right away, and to brace herself for a long search. “First-time homeowners usually see double, sometimes triple the amount of inventory,” he said. “I told her it’s best to see many properties, because it’ll start to cement the end property that you want.”

Ms. Archer knew she didn’t want to cast too wide a net in terms of location. She felt settled in Crown Heights: She loved the proximity to Prospect Park, and knew where to get groceries and her favorite bagels. She would be sharing the new space with her red-haired tabby cat, Scully, and hoped to get a dog in the future, so she needed a pet-friendly building. And as an avid baker, she wanted a kitchen large enough for her pans and tins of flour, as well as large appliances like a KitchenAid mixer.

Ms. Archer began looking seriously in January, and she and Mr. Seegitz spent every weekend for the next two months — including during a blizzard — touring more than 20 apartments.

This charming one-bedroom was on the second floor of a 1930 co-op building with laundry facilities in the basement and a common roof deck. The apartment had an original wood-burning fireplace, a breakfast bar and large, wood-framed windows. Hardwood floors and a dishwasher were added perks. The asking price was $695,000, with monthly maintenance of about $770.

This one-bedroom, on the first floor of a 1920 co-op building with a courtyard, had exposed brick, a window seat and original parquet floors. Updates, including a renovated bathroom and central air-conditioning, had modernized the space. The focal point was the spacious kitchen, which had ample cabinets and new appliances. The price was $675,000, with monthly maintenance of about $670.

Prospect Heights in Need of Work

This one-bedroom, on the third floor of 1915 co-op with a roof deck, was smaller than other units Ms. Archer saw. The bedroom had four built-in closets, but the kitchen lacked storage. The apartment was steps from Grand Army Plaza and Prospect Park, and the asking price of $525,000 would leave Ms. Archer with enough money to renovate the kitchen. The monthly maintenance was about $960.

Find out what happened next by answering these two questions:

Prospect Heights in Need of Work

Prospect Heights in Need of Work

A Comfortable Pied-à-Terre: A couple based in the Catskills could afford up to $400,000 for a place to stay when in the city. Here are the options they found.

Converted Industrial Spaces: After an impulsive move from California, a New York newcomer tested her $1.8 million budget in Manhattan’s loft-filled neighborhoods.

An Upper-West-Side Romance: After college, Lily Kaplan watched her friends leave the neighborhood in favor of cheaper rents. She stuck it out, and found a studio she loves.

Seeking More Room: When their home suddenly became their office, a couple decided it was time to ditch their dark Chelsea rental and seek a larger apartment. What did they find?